Tuesday, October 29, 2013

Music, the Brain, and Pleasure: An Update of Robert Jourdain


Robert Jourdain's Music, the Brain, and Ecstasy is an excellent primer on how the human brain perceives and processes music, covering the musical experience from sound waves reaching the eardrum all the way to the emotional catharsis of a symphony or string quartet. However, since the book's publication in 1997 there has been considerable research not only into the workings of the brain, but also into the neuroscience of music specifically. In this essay I will summarize some of this research in order to update Jourdain's writing on emotion and pleasure in music.

Jourdain (1997) deals with the subject of pleasure in music in the last chapter of the book, titled "Ecstasy." In this chapter, he sets out to answer the following three questions: "First, how is it that music elicits emotions from us? Second, how is it that music gives us pleasure? And third, what is happening in our brains when music leads us to the threshold of ecstasy?" (p. 304) As Jourdain explains, these three questions are intertwined; all are related to anticipation and its fulfillment - or not. Drawing on then-current research, Jourdain explains that emotion stems from the oldest part of the brain, the limbic system, and is important in reasoning (pp. 308-309). Ultimately, emotion is a way for our nervous systems to figure out what activities are most important, a way of directing attention among incoming experiences (p. 309). We plan activities and carry them out by anticipating the results and then satisfying that anticipation (or trying to). Emotions occur when the result does not line up with our anticipation. If the result is better than we expected, we experience a positive emotion; if the result is worse, we experience a negative emotion. Similarly, pleasure is experienced when our expectations or anticipations are fulfilled (p. 312). Unfulfilled expectations cause stress as the brain tries to reassess the situation in order to make a better prediction next time; however, even greater pleasure can be caused by delaying or subverting expectations in order to heighten the sensation of resolution when it finally occurs (p. 319). Music is filled with instances of anticipation and resolution, and as such it makes sense that it should be able to generate both emotions and pleasure in the listener. A well-known example of this is Richard Wagner's opera Tristan und Isolde, whose prelude sets up one unresolved tension after another - tensions that continue for almost the length of the opera, culminating in a tremendous resolution in Isolde's final aria. It is an incredibly evocative depiction of ecstasy, the subject of Jourdain's third question. Of course, the word "ecstasy" is inherently subjective and next to impossible to measure in a scientific way. Jourdain asserts that, "By providing the brain with an artificial environment, and forcing it through that environment in controlled ways, music imparts the means of experiencing relations far deeper than we encounter in our everyday lives... In this perfect world, our brains are able to piece together larger understandings than they can in the workaday world, perceiving all-encompassing relations that go much deeper than those we find in ordinary experience... It's for this reason that music can be transcendent." (p. 331)

Recent research into the science of pleasure and emotion may shed some new light on these ideas. Jourdain notes that, "remarkably, 'pleasure' is a concept seldom encountered in neuroscience or even in psychology. There's hardly a book written on the subject." (p. 315) Happily, this is no longer quite as true as it was in 1997. An iimportant development is that the role of dopamine in musical pleasure is now better understood. A number of studies have examined the role this neurotransmitter plays in music listening, linking musical pleasure to the brain’s reward system. One important study was by Benovoy, Dagher, Larcher, Salimpoor and Zatorre in 2011. In this study, researchers used both PET and fMRI technology to scan subjects who were listening to either a favourite, pleasurable piece of music. Using PET to trace the presence of dopamine and fMRI to determine the timing of dopamine release, the researchers found that chills associated with high levels of pleasure at the climax of a piece of music coincided with the release of dopamine in the nucleus accumbens. Additionally, the researchers found that dopamine spiked about 15 seconds before the emotional climax of the piece as the subject anticipated the most pleasurable section of the music; however, this dopamine activity took place in the caudate (Benovoy et al., 2011). 

This research is intriguing for several reasons. First, it directly links dopamine activity to the experience of musical pleasure, which had not been previously demonstrated. Second, it illustrates that anticipation and fulfillment constitute two different types of musical pleasure that occur in different parts of the brain. The study supports Jourdain's assertion that "...the deepest pleasure in music comes with deviation from the expected... Isn't this contradictory? Not if the deviations serve to set up an even stronger resolution” (Jourdain, 1997, 319). If dopamine is released each time the listener expects a resolution, only to find that the music takes a different turn, the final resolution will be that much more intense, as in Tristan. The study also answers a question raised in the book: "...why we continue to find music expressive after we have heard a piece a few times and know where its expressive deviations will fall." (Jourdain, 1997, 313) Clearly, familiarity with a piece allows the listener to anticipate the most pleasurable moments, releasing dopamine and creating the added pleasure of anticipation. (As an aside, I wonder if this may be why so many musicians and listeners - myself included - become attached to one particular recording of a piece. If we are anticipating certain expressive gestures and don't hear them because the performers have made a different choice, might our anticipation be unfulfilled, leaving us to experience a negative emotion?)

Benovoy et al. (2011) dealt with dopamine activity while listening to a piece of music that the subjects already knew well and loved. But what about unfamiliar music? It is clear that, while familiarity with a piece may increase pleasure in hearing it, unfamiliar music can have the same pleasurable effect. Salimpoor et al. (2013) conducted another experiment to find out what happens in the brain when a subject listens to music that he or she has never heard before. According to Salimpoor and Zatorre (2013), "[i]t has been proposed that all individuals have a 'musical lexicon', which represents a storage system for... information about the relationships between sounds and syntactic rules of music structure specific to their prior experiences” (p. 10434). Or, in other words, throughout the course of their lives, individuals learn the musical rules and structures of their particular culture, allowing them to form expectations and anticipations even when hearing a new piece of music, as long as it falls within their own cultural tradition. In this study, Salimpoor et al. (2013) used fMRI to monitor neural activity while subjects listened to a previously unknown piece of music. They then asked the subjects to rate the desirability of that piece of music by giving them a chance to purchase it in an auction model, so that higher bids demonstrated higher desirability or musical pleasure. They found that highly-rated music coincided with increased activity in the mesolimbic system, particularly the nucleus accumbens - the same area of the brain that was associated with dopamine release upon fulfillment of musical expectations in the previous study. Salimpoor and Zatorre (2013), in a review of studies on musical pleasure, conclude that the cortical system is able to make sense of music's structure and rules and therefore make predictions, while the older striatal dopaminergic system creates the emotional, pleasurable response to music in the brain's reward system. Thus humans are able to take pleasure in an abstract aesthetic reward such as music.

Jourdain’s description of musical pleasure as a series of expectations or anticipations followed by fulfillment is essentially correct; however, the role of dopamine in the neural workings of musical pleasure was not yet understood at the time his book was published. Recent research confirms Jourdain’s assertions and helps us to understand how the abstract pleasure of music taps into our evolved rewards systems.




Works Cited


Jourdain, R. (1997). Music, the brain, and ecstasy: How music captures our imagination. New York, NY: Harper Perennial.


Benovoy, M., Dagher, A., Larcher, K., Salimpoor, V.N., and Zatorre, R.J. (2011). Anatomically distinct dopamine release during anticipation and experience of peak emotion to music. Nature Neuroscience, 14(2), 257-262. http://dx.doi.org.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/10.1038/nn.2726


Salimpoor, V.N., van den Bosch, I., Kovacevic, N., McIntosh, A.R., Dagher, A., and Zatorre, R.J. (2013). Interactions between the nucleus accumbens and auditory cortices predict music reward value. Science 30(6129), 216-219. doi: 10.1126/science.1231059.

Zatorre, R.J., and Salimpoor, V.N. (2013). From perception to pleasure: Music and its neural substrates. 
PNAS 110(2), 10430-10437. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1301228110

The Efficient practice method


        People who study music, including myself, desire to be great musicians and performers but as we may know, becoming virtuosi is not easy; in fact, only few can reach to that level. However, to achieve our goal or dream, we, musicians, practice every day over and over since we all heard of ‘Practice makes perfect!’ Unfortunately, this theory does not work to become a perfect player; then what is the problem? In Robert Jourdain’s book, Music, The brain and Ecstasy, in ‘to performance’ section, he stated, “Researchers have found marked differences between the practice styles of amateurs and virtuosi”(Jourdain, 233) meaning that although practicing hard may be one of important components, how to practice efficiently is the main key to success. This paper will demonstrate the efficient practice method to become a great performer.

            Firstly, in Jourdain’s book, he compared the practice styles of amateurs and virtuosi; amateurs usually just like to play long passages straight through, but when they have some faulty notes, they stop and repeat several times. In other hands, virtuosi only concentrate on fragments rather than playing the entire piece and they correct the faulty notes by playing them in the context of a larger phrase. Since virtuosi understand that the bad notes are from in the motions for the notes around it, “they correct wrong notes by working on the relations between notes, by working on the relations between notes, by reorganizing the deeper levels in the motor and conceptual hierarchies from which the notes arise.”(Jourdain, 233) In addition, repeating same mistakes over and over is very fatal which means before our muscle memorized the wrong motions, we have to practice just that fragments to make it perfect. From my own experience, practicing on the specific fragments that I made mistake to make it perfect, is one of the hardest part of my practice session; it requires much endeavor and patience. It also relates to habit that some people, including myself, just skip thru mistakes after few trials hoping that they will get it right next time.

           Furthermore, there is “a strong correlation between quality of performance and amount of practice” (Jourdain, 233) which indicates that the quantity of practice is also important. As we can see, the top performers or at least better performers than us, usually practice constantly everyday with right method and spends more practicing time than us. For example, the world renowned violinist, Jascha Heifetz said that he had played the violin for 100,000 hours, roughly an eight-hour day six days per week from early childhood. On the contrary, some people like Paganini and Liszt, they only practiced incessantly in earlier age and hardly at all later which may view as the quantity and quality of practice is crucial especially in early age. Of course, there are advantages for people who are born with ‘talent’ and learned instrument in earlier age to become virtuosi but I insist that with efficient practice method and effort for a long term period also can lead to virtuosic level for those who are not born with it.

            Moreover, the study Learning strategies in instrumental music practice by Siw G.Nielsen, the author lays out a primary strategies in practice. The first step is strategies to select relevant parts of learning material: a visual examination of the score, playing through larger section in a tempo close to final tempo. Second step is strategies to organize and to form relation in the learning material which includes repeating parts in different segments, repeating segments in different tempi using the metronome, using combinations of strategies in sequence and dividing the piece into ‘working areas’ that are focused separately. Lastly, strategies to relate the learning material to existing knowledge: playing segments along with a vocal expression and listening to others’ performance and recording. Personally, idea of working with metronome is the most important strategy, especially in early stage of learning a new piece: setting up the tempo really slow to make it perfect and gradually increasing speed to achieve final tempo. For contemporary piece, since there are many complex rhythms, harmonies, and techniques, using metronome is mandatory. In the past, I had many troubles in piece just because I did not work with metronome and as some people may experience, sometimes, we are too lazy to work with metronome.

            Lastly, according to study, Self-regulating learning strategies in instrumental music practice by Siw Nielsen, self-evaluation, setting of specific goals, strategic planning, self-instruction, and self-monitoring help students to enable to optimise their learning and performances, taking into account interpersonal, contextual and interpersonal conditions. Interestingly, in this study, verbal techniques might prove valuable. For example, the student might be taught to ask and answer questions such as: ‘What is my problem?’, ‘How can I solve it?’ ‘How am I doing?’ during practice. “These questions probably have the effect of increasing the students’ metacognitive awareness of the demands of a problem and the specific strategic effort that is well matched to it. The implication is that to promote skilful self-regulatory learning teachers must support students to learn how to orchestrate their strategic activities reflectively, in the face of fluctuating problems” (Butler, 1998).

            In conclusion, it would be great if you can ask yourself, ‘how efficient practice am I doing?’ The amount of practicing time may important but the efficiency and quality of practice is the main key. Of course, it would be hard to follow every single method and strategies; however, we may pick up some of points where we need to improve on and put them into action. At first, due to our old habits, we may struggle but once we get used to these great principles, we can achieve to certain high-level performer later on. Rather than blaming oneself about talent issue, working hard in right ways with endeavor and patience will lead us to great musicians.

Bibliography

BUTLER, D.L. (1998) A strategic content learning approach to promoting self-regulate d learning by students with learning disabilities , in: D.H. SCHUNCK & B.J. ZIMMERMAN (Eds) Self-regulated Learning. From Teaching to Self-reflective Practice (New York, The Guilford Press).

 
Jourdain, R. (1997). Music, the Brain, and Ecstasy: How Music Captures Our Imagination. HarperCollins.

Siw Nielsen (2001) Self-regulating Learning Strategies in Instrumental Music Practice, Music Education Research, 3:2, 155-167, DOI: 10.1080/14613800120089223

Music and Emotion





              People often complain that music is too ambiguous, that what they should
              think when they hear it is so unclear, whereas everyone understands words.
              With me, it is exactly the opposite, and not only with regard to an entire
              speech, but also with individual words.
             These seem to me so ambiguous, so vague, so easily misunderstood in
             comparison to genuine music, which fills the soul with a thousand things
             better than words. [1]
                                                                                                    Felix Mendelssohn
            

           

The question is posed “does music arouse emotion?” Then the debate unfolds… does music have emotion “written in to it” causing the listener to recognize and feel it, does the listener respond because they are associating an emotion to the character of the music, or a specific memory to the song?   Emotion in the music or emotion associated to the music. Convincing arguments from both perspectives can be found.  Although why we respond emotionally to music may be debated, there is no debate as to whether or not music arouses emotion. 

This paper will explore the question:  Why do we respond emotionally to music?

Robert Jourdain, in his book Music, The Brain, and Ecstasy [2], considers a number of questions regarding music and emotion including how does music elicit an emotional response.  He explores musical pleasure and also ecstasy, which he describes as “pleasure taken to extremes”.

Upon first entering the chapter, I asked myself how far I wanted to explore this topic.  Would dissecting the experience of emotional response to music and placing it under a microscope result in a diminished level of emotional pleasure or response when listening of personally significant music in the future?  When listening to music, would my attention shift to self-study and awareness, noting my responses to, rather then experience the joy of, music?  Would I only listen to musical structure and form, noting their potential to impact me?  The mystery of music is part of the joy of the musical experience. But as I reflected on all of this, curiosity got the best of me.  Why do I respond emotionally to music?  I read on….

Jourdain described the arousal of emotion to music as a result of the experience of anticipation and fulfillment. He commented that disappointment is only felt as a disappointment because something did not unfold as anticipated.  In other words, the emotion could have been at best “neutral”, or better, pleasure, if the situation did in fact unfold as anticipated.   Anticipation prepares one for disappointment or the pleasure of fulfillment: anticipation prepares us for emotion. When listening to music, anticipation of where the music is going sets the listener up for fulfillment and the resulting sense of pleasure.  Jourdain describes how the unexpected, the “violation of our expectation”, is a component of expressiveness.  In addition to experiencing the pleasure of musical fulfillment, the unexpected, the unanticipated, also contributes to the emotional experience.  In fact, Jourdain notes that music that is regular and predictable is rejected by the brain.  We become bored.  There are no changes to track, no surprises to grab our attention.

Jourdain states that the “deepest pleasure in music comes with deviation from the expected”.   He goes on to discuss examples of deviation in harmony, melodic contour, and rhythm and how they contribute to the musical anticipation-fulfillment experience, to an emotional response in the listener.

Jourdain commented that the discomfort of new music may be a result of the listener not yet knowing how to anticipate within that form.  I considered this as I reflected on the music-sharing times I have with my eighteen-year-old son.  His music is not my personal preference, yet because it is an opportunity to be with my son, I regularly sit with him so that he can share his “latest favourites” with me.   He enthusiastically points out musical details of interest to him, the harmonic textures and rhythmic complexities.  He hears things that I don’t.  Instead, I’m focused on how disorganized it feels, how distant it is from the logic and stability of Baroque music, for example.   Jourdain is right.  I do not know how to listen to this music.  I can now determine to seek out musical elements and learn to anticipant where they might go (or not).  Jourdain’s chapter has not yet reduced my emotional response to music, in fact, it may have increased the opportunity.

Jourdain sparked an interest in considerations to emotional response to music. I decided to compare Jourdain’s comments with more recent literature.

Jourdain’s observations and insights regarding contributing factors to emotional response to music are reflected in research results on this topic.  A number of studies support Jourdain’s proposal that emotional responses to music are a result of musical expectancy or anticipation, the possible suspension of this, and its fulfillment.

Steinbeis, Koelsch, and Sloboda [3] concluded in their study that emotions elicited while listening to music are a result of the experience of suspension and fulfillment of musical expectations.  They stated that the level of emotion increases with the suspension.  Their study focused on harmonic expectations.  Using self-report, electrodermal measurements and EEG recordings, they analyzed participant’s responses to unexpected (altered) harmonic sequences in Bach chorales.  They noted that harmonically unexpected events aroused emotion, activating the orbital fronatolateral cortex.  They suggested that the unexpected harmonies served to increase physiological arousal, which in turn increase emotional response. 

Meyer [4] also proposesd that musical emotions are a response to suspended or fulfilled expectations.  Chord progressions developed by Kowlsch and Friederici [5] were originally created to study music processing.  However, it was noted that the unexpected harmonic structure of some of the chords aroused the orbital frontolateral cortex, implicated in the processing of emotion.  The unexpectedness of the harmonic sequence resulted in emotional arousal in the listeners.

Koelshch [6] includes the idea that unexpected harmony or chord structures contribute to tension and that tension is associated with emotional experiences.  The creation of tension and release adds another dimension to expectation and fulfillment.

Another study [7] explored the emotional processing of major, minor, and dissonant chords.   Using brain imaging, the study examined individual’s responses to single chords.  Minor and dissonant chords elicited stronger BOLD (blood-oxygen level-dependent) responses than major chords in the amygdala, retrosplenial cortex, brain stem and cerebellum.  Koelsch et al [6] also noted increased BOLD activation in the amygdala, hippocampus, parahippocampus gyrus, and the temporal poles when study participants listened to unpleasant music.  This increase in activation while listening to unpleasant music is believed to be an inhibitation, rather than an excitation of synaptic activity.

These studies which reported results of emotional arousal after short chord progressions or after single chords leads to the question: how much music does one need to listen to in order to have an emotional response?   Joudain and others state that emotional arousal is in response to an experience of expectation and fulfillment.  A few chords or a single chord of a specific quality do not allow enough time for a build up of expectation and fulfillment. 

Bigand, Filipic, and Lalitte [8] explored the question of time course for emotional responses to music.  In their study, participants listened to musical excerpts that were 1 second long and 25 seconds long.  Listeners were asked to categorize the musical excerpts by emotion.  They concluded from their results that even 1 second was enough for listeners to have an emotional response.  I doubt, however, that in 1 second any listener actually had an emotional arousal but rather an observation of the emotional tone or quality of the sound. 

Krumhansl[9] concluded in his study that listener’s emotional response increased over time.  I agree with this, and it reflects the listener’s opportunity to experience anticipation and fulfillment, to have tension build up and resolve, and to hear unexpected harmonic textures or progressions which heighten musical expectation.

When discussing emotional responses to music, several studies included physiological responses as part of that process.  Grewe, Nagel, Kopiez, and Altenmuller [10] explored how music can give the listener “chills”.  Although literal chills are rare, they happened during musical structural elements.  Their study revealed the main contributors to emotional arousal include harmonic sequences, entrance of a voice, and the “violation of expectation”.  They also highlighted a theme that other studies included here overlooked.  They commented that strong emotions in response to music “do not occur in a reflex-like manner, but as a result of attentive, experienced, and conscious musical enjoyment”.


How does music arouse emotion?

Well- written music engages our attention through its unfolding structure.  We follow it and our anticipation builds, we are awaiting fulfillment. Unexpected harmonies, chord progressions, dynamic changes, or phrase contours arouse a response and suspend our fulfillment.  This suspension increases the anticipation and sweetens the fulfillment.  Dissonance adds the element of tension which also arouses emotion. The resolution of tension adds yet another level of fulfillment. 

Add to this the expressiveness woven into the music by the performers, plus any personal associations or memories to the music and you have a toxic mix, perfect for an emotional response. 

As a listener, does this information diminish the emotional impact of music?  Does it strip music down to structural elements and formula?  Has emotional response been reduced to a reflex to a trigger?

No.  This serves to increase the appreciation of well- crafted music.  It informs the process of composing.  It acknowledges the joy of discovery, the need to find new, the challenge and stimulation of the unexpected, and the ecstasy of fulfillment.




Music can noble hints impart,

Engender fury, kindle love,

With unsuspected eloquence can move,

And manage all the man with secret art.

~Joseph Addison







References


     7dfwd7gW4flC.997.dfwd.
2. Jourdain, R. 2002.  Music, the brain, and ecstasy. Harper Perennial Publishers.
3. Steinbeis, N., Koelsch, S., & Sloboda, J. 2005.  Emotional processing of harmonic
    expectancy violations. Ann.N.Y. Sci. 1060:457-461.
4.  Meyer, L.B. 1956. Emotion and meaning in music.  University of Chicago Press,
     Chicago.
5.Koelsch,S.T., Fritz, K., Schulze, K. et al. 2005. Adults and children processing
    music:  an fMRI study. Neuroimage 25: 1068-1076.
6. Koelsch, F. 2005. Investigating emotion with music neuroscientific approaches.
     Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 1060:412-418.
7. Pallesen, K.J., Brattico, E., Bailey, C., Korvenoja, A., Koivisto, J., Gjedde,A., and
    Carlson, S. 2005. Emotion processing of major, minor, and dissonant chords. A
    functional magnetic resonance imaging study. Ann.N.Y. Acad.Sci. 1060: 450-453.
8. Bigand, E., Filipic, S. & Lalitte, P. 2005. The Time Course of Emotional Responses
    to Music. Ann. N.Y. Sci. 1060:429-437.
9.  Krumhansl, C.L. 1997. An exploratory study of musical emotions and
     psychophysiology . Can. J. Exp. Psychol.51: 336-353.
10.Grewe, O., Nagel, F., Kopiez,R., & Altenmuller, E. How does music arouse “chills”?
   Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 1060:446-449.

Thursday, October 24, 2013

Musical Hallucinations


Reference:
Stefan Evers, MD, PhD – “Musical Hallucinations”
Current Psychiatry Reports, 2006, 8:205–210


In “Musical Hallucinations,” Stefan Evers discusses several reported cases of various etiologies of musical hallucinations. The author also provides a model of categorization and opens the debate on possible pathophysiologic mechanisms. According to Evers, musical hallucinations are disorders resulting from complex sound processings in which patients hear instrumental music, songs, but also isolated sounds. Interestingly, people with damaged hearing are more likely to experience these sorts of musical hallucinations. In most cases, patients are aware of the distortive nature of their perception. The author dates the first documented case of musical hallucinations back to 1846.
Evers then proceeds to review a study conducted by German E. Berrios. In the study, called “Musical hallucinations: a historical and clinical study,” Berrios analyzed 46 cases. Of all the patients, 67% were nearly or completely deaf. Brain diseases such as tumors or strokes were discovered in 39% of all patients. Berrios noticed that musical hallucinations are more likely to affect elderly women with damaged hearing or brain diseases, but without any history of psychiatric illness.
Evers follows the review of Berrios’ work with assessment of a study done by group of  investigators lead by Matcheri Keshavan, professor of psychiatry in the Department of Psychiatry at Harvard Medical School. Of all causes for musical hallucinations, this group suggested that deafness is the most important one. According to them, brain damage relates to hallucinations to a lesser degree. As it was the case in Berrios’ study, this work showed that females are more likely to be affected by this disorder. Keshavan’s study also revealed that right-sided brainstem lesions are insignificantly more connected to this disorder then left-side lesions. Among many studies which Evers reviewed throughout his article, the most interesting is Saba and Keshavan’s. The study, performed in 1997 and called “Musical hallucinations and musical imagery: Prevalence and phenomenology in schizophrenic patients” examined 100 patients with schizophrenia. Of all these patience only 16 of them experienced musical hallucinations, and 56% of them were males. Evers, however, does not consider this study as representative because the authors observed only patients with acute auditory hallucinations.
After reviewing various studies and cases, Evers provides statistical information regarding the demographic and clinical status of all patients involved. Ages range from 20 to 90 years; 70% of all patients were females. In 27% of the cases, a localized brain lesion or a localized epileptic focus was described, but the occurrence of musical hallucinations did  not  depend  on  the  side  of  the  lesion. Exact chronicity of this disorder, however, is not clearly known. Musical hallucinations have been the focus of studies only in 0.16% of all general hospital setting examinations. When elderly subjects experiencing audiologic complaints have been studied, the frequency of musical hallucinations was 2.5%. More than one fifth of all psychiatric patients, however, have sometimes experienced musical hallucinations.
Evers then redirects his focus of attention towards categorizing the disorder’s etiologies. The first impairment he examines is Hypacusis, a hearing impairment of a conductive or neurosensory nature sometimes described as a partial deafness. In 50% of all patients, hypacusis was a predominant etiologic factor for musical hallucinations. 77% of all patients were females with the average age of 71 (± 15 years). Psychiatric disorders are factors that have been commonly considered as an important element for initiating musical hallucinations; Evers states that of all patients, depression was diagnosed in 45% of them, schizophrenia in 35%, obsessive-compulsive disorder in 10%, and neurotic symptoms in 5%. 68% of all patients were females with the average age of 51 (± 21 years). Focal brain lesions were diagnosed as the fundamental cause of musical hallucinations for a certain number of patients. In 62% of them, lesion was detected in the right hemisphere, while 38% of all patients had lesion located in the left hemisphere. 62% of all patients were female with the average age of 50 (± 16 years). In most patients, the brain lesion was vascular in nature or a tumor. In a small number of them factors such as epilepsy or intoxication were found to be the main generator of the musical hallucinations. Again, most of them were females. Evers here provides the list of chemical agents with a strong potential of fueling musical hallucinations, such as propranolol, clomipramine, marijuana, paracetamol, alcohol, and others.
According to one study, religious songs, childhood songs, and popular songs from the radio are what most patients with musical hallucinations describe. Evers recalls Nick Warner and Victor Aziz and their work “Hymns and arias: Musical hallucinations in older people in Wales;” in the study they state that in most cases older patients seem to imagine religious songs. Classical music was perceived in about 10% of the cases, while folk music in slightly higher percentage – 12%. Furthermore, a higher percentage of the perceived music was vocal than instrumental: 26% against 10%. But the most common perceived music was both, vocal and instrumental – 47%. Interestingly, 80% of patients found hallucinations to be frightening, while 20% of patients actually enjoyed them. Evers here goes back to the work of Matcheri Keshavan, who states that musical hallucinations are sometimes closely related to personal memory of patients. Keshavan has also introduced a concept called “parasitic memory,” where hallucinations can be derived from re-experiencing of stored musical experiences and stimulation of the specific neuronal circuit.
When it comes to treatment of this disorder, Evers has noted that no specific information on treatment was given so far. Single cases have been treated successfully with neuroleptic, antidepressive, and anticonvulsive drugs. The author, however, provides the results of a research performed by a group of authors under the guidance of Mark Collins. The paper “Pilot study of treatment of persistent auditory hallucinations by modified auditory input” revisits the case of a 53-year-old psychotic woman for whom listening to music was more efficient in eliminating the voices heard than medical treatment. How diverse etiologies of this disorder can be, describes the case of a 61-year-old woman who after clipping of two small aneurysms, didn’t experience any hallucinations. This case was examined in the study called “Musical hallucinations associated with seizures originating from an intracranial aneurysm” by a group of authors working with Daniel Roberts. For patients suffering from schizophrenia, antidepressive medications seemed to improve hallucination related issues. The documented reaction of a great number of patients to carbamazepine was promising.
                The author underlines that there is no clear evidence of a fundamental cause for musical hallucinations. However, hearing loss or deafness is the most discussed factor related to this disorder. Anthony Gordon in his study “Do musical hallucinations always arise from the inner ear?” discusses the inner ear disease which leads to a sort of “a hyperactive state of the ear.” On the other side, there are patients experiencing musical hallucinations without such symptoms. Brain imaging studies have shown some association with dysfunction of the temporal cortex, specifically in the left lobe. Therefore, Evers states, there is a possibility that some cases  of  musical  hallucinations are associated with focal brain damage or with associated clinical epilepsy. Memory is also an important factor when this disorder is discussed. As mentioned before, according to Keshavan and his concept of “parasitic memory,” musical perception represents a deep-rooted part of memory and can be experienced by external stimuli or simply by chance.
                Musical hallucinations are a phenomenon that has not been greatly researched and Evers’ work offers an important insight into this disorder. The fact that patients hear familiar tunes from the past supports the argument on the importance of memory in this kind of hallucinations. Recently, however, one unique form of musical hallucinations has been reported. A 60-year-old woman heard songs that she could not identify, but she realized that all of the songs she heard are familiar to her husband. This is the first case of somebody experiencing musical hallucinations with songs familiar to people from his or her environment. This is something Evers did not know at the time he made his study. Another important aspect of musical hallucinations in my opinion is related to professional musicians. In their study “Musical hallucinations in a musician,” Jason Warren and Jonathan Schott describe hallucinations of an 83-year-old musician who was able to notate his hallucinations. Their observation is focused on abnormal spontaneous activities in auditory cortical areas beyond the primary auditory cortex. But auditory hallucinations are not the only cases of musical hallucinations that patients experienced. The cases of notation hallucinations have also been reported. All patients who experienced this kind of hallucinations have some kind of musical knowledge that again stresses importance which memory has in this phenomena.



Wednesday, October 23, 2013

Music and the Brain: Wednesday is Indigo Blue: How Synesthesia Speaks to Creativity

                                                                       

Music and Synesthesia

Source: Cytowic, Richard, Music and the Brain: Wednesday is Indigo Blue: How Synesthesia Speaks to 
            Creativity, Oct. 2009, Web. 21 Oct 2013, Library Congress, 
            Washington, D.C., http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ex8UYOJtddA                            

Review:
Richard Cytowic discusses some of the science behind synesthesia (the automatic combination of two or more bodily senses). He mentions that most people have some sort of synesthesia (i.e. grapheme-colour, phoneme-colour, etc.). For example, most people go to the movies for the visual-and-audio combination effect, and many people find it troubling when the visual and audio cues are not aligned with one another. Synesthesia tends to run in families, and it “may be the first cognitive trait which science can map out its gene.” The phenomenon is also more common in people who are artistic (such as musicians like Messaien and Scriabin) and in blind people.

Interestingly, synesthesia itself cannot be located in the brain; the reaction can only be seen when parts of the brain are activated.  Cytowic explains that synesthesia is caused by a gene mutation which results in decrease in inhibition (known as stroop interference) of one bodily sense and, consequently, hyperactivity or excitation in the brain when bodily senses are blended. Specifically, certain areas of the brain, which are loosely connected in non-synesthetes, are interconnected in synesthetes. This is known as the breakdown of modularity. Synesthetes seem to have increased excitation when they hear a sound, see an object, etc. For example, grapheme-colour synesthetes often experience seeing words in colour through an activation of the V4 color area in the fusiform gyrus (which is a part of the temporal and occipital lobes) and the angular gyrus (which is a part of the parietal lobe). The fusiform gyrus is responsible for face, body, colour-and-word- recognition while the angular gyrus is responsible for language processing and lexical semantics. This activation of the fusiform gyrus and angular gyrus can be seen on a positron emission tomography (PET) scan. The connection between words and colour are not as strong in non-synesthetes due to the increased inhibition of the angular gyrus.

This excitation-inhibition link is crucial in facilitating creativity. For instance, melodic improvisation involves listening to a previous tune, and then using your judgement on developing the melodic line and "making it your own." If you think too much about having the melodic line sound "right," that thought will impede your ability to improvise. Having synesthesia would be an advantage, in that you would be more likely to improvise music more confidently without the breaking of modularity standing in the way. Similarly, composing and performing your own music involves using elements of music (i.e. melody, harmony, timbre, form, etc.) for the purpose of displaying how you see the world. Musicians such as Messiaen and Scriabin were known for experimenting with keys and modes as colours, contributing to their creativity. In short, synesthesia is a stepping stone into the further understanding into creativity by scientists.

Reflection:
The information in this video clip was insightful, especially regarding the excitation- inhibition link and the differences between synesthetes and non-synesthetes. In particular, I was interested in the scans in the colour-hearing synesthetes, and I have always wondered if someone with synesthesia could teach perfect pitch to themselves. I have relatives who have perfect pitch, but I am not sure whether they have synesthesia as well.

Almost 30 years ago, my parents gave me an alphabet stand with colour-coded letters and slots in the stand. I kept putting the letters in the slots, simultaneously being astonished by the letters’ bright colours. Three years later, I was experimenting and playing with the piano keys for a year prior to formal musical training. My inspiration and interest in “memorizing the keys by ear” came about by listening and watching Stevie Wonder and Ray Charles perform their works on the radio and on TV respectively. In my younger mind, I had wondered how blind musicians were able to play their instruments with such accuracy and passion, and I had decided that I would close my eyes whenever I sat at the piano. I decided that my personal musical success would be marked by playing songs with my eyes closed, and it was only then that I would be able to call myself a musician. 

As I was playing the piano, I noticed that I was memorizing the keys - by colours. I was connecting the notes to the colour-coded alphabet stand letters. There were no note names from me to draw from, for I was not taking music lessons at this time. Later in my life (after taking private piano lessons), I was connecting major and minor chords with different types of weather. This phenomenon felt weird to me, in the sense that I had an instinct that everyone was not experiencing music in the same way (hearing music in colour). Improvising on the piano was as almost as easy to me as walking, and writing music before finishing my elementary school years felt like jogging; it felt natural to me. Classmates would ask questions on how I was able to play along to songs that I had never heard before so easily, and I would respond by saying, “I don’t know!”

I am not sure whether or not I “taught myself perfect pitch” with the help of my colour-hearing synesthesia. What I know is that my synesthesia has helped me to be musically creative. “Seeing sounds” and “hearing colours” in music have facilitated my musical arrangements for choirs and orchestras, and it has helped me in providing different approaches to students on reading and memorizing songs. Today, I am able to sight-read music at a fairly fast pace, and I can play simple songs with my eyes closed. I do not feel that I have a barrier when it comes to playing unknown pieces. I feel that I have reached my own definition of a musician.

Tuesday, October 22, 2013

Musical Training Enhances Neural Processing of Binaural Sounds

Musical Training Enhances Neural Processing of Binaural Sounds

Source:
Parbery-Clark, A., Strait, D.L., Hittner, E., Kraus, N. 2013 Musical Training Enhances Neural Processing of Binaural Sounds. The Journal of Neuroscience, 33(42):16741-16747.
http://www.jneurosci.org/content/33/42/16741.short

Summary:

 In this paper Parbery-Clark et al address their hypothesis that musicians' strengthened auditory processing is related to enhanced diotic listening, and that this enhancement relates to their superior hearing in noise.

 Binaural hearing refers to auditory processing of incoming sounds from both ears, and is critical in order to hear within loud, complex listening environments. The human brain can detect differences in incoming sounds between the left and right ears on the order of tens to hundreds of microseconds (10^-6 seconds!). This is crucial for hearing in noisy environments because the auditory system uses timing mechanisms to segregate concurrent sounds according to slight differences in location, pitch, and sound quality. Diotic hearing is binaural hearing in which both ears experience the same sounds at the same time.

 Musicians appear to have an over-average ability to manage complex auditory environments and have increased perceptual learning abilities. Studies suggest that music training may be linked to strengthened perception, and neural encoding of speech in the presence of noise. These enhanced abilities, however, have never been directly compared in monaural (hearing sound through only one ear) and diotic circumstances.

 In lay terms: this experiment set out to answer the question of whether or not these enhanced auditory processing abilities in musicians involved diotoic hearing specifically.

 In order to address this question, Parbery-Clark et al measured speech-evoked auditory brainstem responses (ABRs) of musicians and non-musicians via scalp electrodes. The electrode signals were analyzed to measure neural response amplitude and neural timing. The hypothesis was that musicians would have faster neural timing and increased amplitudes of response peaks (i.e. that they process quicker, and the magnitude of neural response would be greater). Musician groups included anyone who had consistently practiced an instrument at least 3 times a week since 7 years of age. Non-musician groups included subjects that had less than 3 years of musical training at any point in their lifetime. In total, this study included 30 participants with 15 musicians and 15 non-musicians. The auditory component of the ABRs was a 40ms speech syllable, /da/, which was presented either monaurally on the left or right side, or diotically, via inserted headphones.

 For the assessment of speech-in-noise, this group used the "Hearing in Noise Test" from Biologic Systems. Here, the participants were asked to repeat 20 short sentences that were heard with acoustically fixed background noise from a loudspeaker. The performance was assessed based on the minimal intensity of the target sentence, relative to the background noise, at which the participant could correctly repeat at least 50% of the target sentences.

 The results demonstrate that musicians exhibit faster neural timing and more consistent responses when presented with diotic ques, but musicians and non-musicians performed equally well monoaurally. Musicians also had better speech-in-noise performance. Intriguingly, musicians and non-musicians both exhibited faster neural timing peaks after diotic ques, but this difference was more drastic in the musician group. Across all subjects, faster neural response and greater magnitude of that response after diotic stimuli, were directly correlated with better speech-in-noise perception.

 These results support the use of music training in treatment of compromised binaural processing. Also, the average elementary school classroom has a decibel level of approximately 60. A normal conversation would generally take place at 50 decibels. This noise level creates obvious barriers to learning; however, music training would enhance a child's speech-in-noise perception and would thereby improve their learning experience.


Response:

 I thoroughly enjoyed this paper. I feel the authors had a meticulous experimental plan, which used three distinct controls. These included an initial test with all subjects measuring neural timing response to a 100 microsecond click stimulus- which tests their general neural response and ensures that they were all within a normal range, irrespective of musical training- a 35 microvolt signal boundary that differentiates between true signal and artifacts, and randomized application of diotic and monaural conditions across the subjects to rule out contributions due to neural fatigue and adaptation between environments.

 The authors also mentioned that other experiments had conversely found an increase in monaural processing in musicians; however, the authors suggest that because the syllable cue used did not contain the acoustically rich vowel portion, this removed the advantage. This decision was based on previous studies that link the acoustically rich vowel portion of a syllable with musicians' enhanced neural encoding of the spectral components in speech. These results indicate that this was indeed the case, and this further illustrates the depth, and thoroughness with which Parbery-Clark et al approached their experimental design.

 I have a very limited understanding of ABR, but from the information provided in this paper, this method of measuring neural response seems robust and reliable. These results indicate a statistically significant correlation between enhanced diotic auditory processing and speech-in-noise perception, and more importantly, this scientifically proves a measurable increase in cognitive performance based on musical training. Music training does apparently make you smarter!

 The only critique I can offer for this paper is that in the discussion, the correlation between music training and increased speech-in-noise perception was proposed to be a result of ensemble playing or conducting. This suggests that the speech-in-noise perception enhancement would not result from private lessons or individual practice, which is in direct contrast with their concluding statement that music lessons in general would illicit these benefits (Practical Applications section). Also, just because the diotic processing and speech-in-noise perception were correlated, does not mean that diotic processing is solely responsible for this benefit. I think this study proves that they are both increased due to music training, and perhaps this enhancement is due to increased diotic processing, but there may be a large assortment of factors that contribute to this,that are equally enhanced with music training, such as: acoustically rich vowel recognition, or non-diotic binaural processing.

 Overall, I found this study to be thorough, informative, and scientifically satisfying. I would be intrigued to see if the speech-in-noise perception increase varies with soloist musicians vs. ensemble players, but every study must leave something for the next person :).