Tuesday, October 22, 2013

Building the Musical Muscle

Source
Limb, Charles, Dr. "Charles Limb: Building the Musical Muscle." TED: Ideas worth Spreading. N.p., Dec. 2011. Web. 20 Oct. 2013. http://www.ted.com/talks/charles_limb_building_the_musical_muscle.html

Summary
When we think about our senses, we don’t tend to think about them in terms of using our senses to protect ourselves. Nowadays, our senses want beauty, not so much function.

Music is an acoustic vibration in the air that tickles our ear drum. The vibration transmits into energy through our hearing bone that gets converted into a fluid inside the cochlear. It then gets converted into an electrical signal in our auditory nerves and ends up in our brain as a perception.

Many people lose hearing at the cochlear level. According to Dr. Limb, as a surgeon, he would recommend losing hearing compared to another sense because it is scientifically the most advance in research. However, as a musician, he says that receiving a cochlear implant is very heartbreaking.

Scenario #1: A girl born deaf and is growing up in a very supportive environment. She has received cochlear implants and 10 years later, she is talking and responding to interview questions regarding a book she wrote about being deaf. The girl goes on speaking about the benefits of having a cochlear implant because she will remove it when she doesn’t want to listen.

Many cochlear implant users struggle to hear music because it sounds very bad. Language is very precise and we do not care whether or not it sounds pretty. Music on the other hand, it something we listen to because it sounds pretty. Dr. Limb’s goal is to design a cochlear implant with music as the ultimate goal and better pitch perception.

A demonstration using MIDI files compared a piece of music that was played normally and then the same piece of music that was randomly distorted to be at least one semitone away from the actual pitch. This demonstrated what cochlear implant users hear. Another demonstration illustrates that cochlear users cannot identify instruments apart. They cochlear implants lack the ability to distinguish the difference between sound and timber quality.

Scenario #2: Joseph is performing a piece of music on the piano after 3 years of receiving cochlear implants. Even though he received powerful hearing aids, they were not helping his learning process. Dr. Limb continues and says that people can play piano without cochlear implants because it is a matter of training the brain to press buttons at the right time. Even people like Beethoven, who couldn’t hear, music and the brain have a special hard wired relationship.

Dr. Limb concludes with the following idea that we’ve come a long way, but we still have a long way to go. The restoration of basic function is OK, but we want the restoration of beauty.


Reflection
Dr. Limb speaks on the importance of having music as the ultimate goal when it comes to restoring hearing. Music is considered an aesthetic beauty and it is very important that we can share this ultimate beauty with everyone.

According to other research, Musical Pitch Discrimination by Cochlear Implant Users (Ping, Lichuan; Yuan Meng; Feng Haihong, May 2012), cochlear implant users can detect the presence of changes of pitch more accurately than they can perceive the direction of changes in the pitches. Clear and regular harmonic structure in the lower-frequency channels will help cochlear implant users with pitch discrimination. The performance will decrease when there is interference in the high-frequency channels.

As a student, I had classmates who were hard of hearing. The teacher would speak through a FM transmitter and they would have an interpreter in the class signing. I recall my classmates received hearing aids as they did a combination of reading our facial expressions and tried to listen to our pronunciation. They were integrated in our class during math, science/social studies and physical education. The other times, they had their own teacher which modified the curriculum to meet their needs in the other subject areas. After watching the video of the little girl who had fluent oral communication skills, it makes me wonder whether children who receive treatment early can become more successful at learning to speak.

If I have students with cochlear implants, I would ensure that I integrate the students into the classroom as much as possible so they have an opportunity to build social skills. With the advancement of science and technology, cochlear implants will become more accurate and these students can engage in music class. According to the study, if we use lower frequency channels, pitch distinction will become easier for the cochlear implant user. Even though that limits our musical exposure, it does allow cochlear implant users to participate in musical experiences.
 
Reference
Ping, Lichuan, Meng Yuan, and Haihong Feng. "Musical Pitch Discrimination by Cochlear Implant Users." The Annals of Otology, Rhinology & Laryngology 121.5 (2012): 328-36. Proquest. Web. 20 Oct. 2013. <http://search.proquest.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/docview/1018153457/abstract?accountid=14771>.

The Neuroscience of Personality


The Neuroscience of Personality

In this talk, part of the "Authors at Google" series, Dario Nardi, Ph.D, presents a summary of his research into the neuroscience of personality type, specifically the sixteen types of the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator. Dr. Nardi conducted a 5-year research project (which he describes as a "big pilot study") in which he monitored the brains of students ages 18-25, while they performed a range of tasks and activities, using an EEG. Each student had taken the MBTI and had ten weeks in which to determine their best-fit personality type. In the lab, the students performed activities such as playing card or word games, physical tasks such as juggling, memory tasks such as recalling items on a list or in a visual scene, and thinking tasks such as math or analogies. They communicated with others in a variety of formats such as simulated speed-dating or role-playing with actors. Each student also engaged in an area in which they had a level of expertise, such as music or dance. Overall, each student spent between 2-3 hours in the lab. The data that Dr. Nardi collected over this period suggests that although each brain is different and individual, persons of the same personality type will show significantly similar activity (for instance, two ENFPs have a 50% chance of having 80% of their brain activity be the same). In fact, at one point Dr. Nardi responded to a question by stating that if he were to see only the aggregate of someone's EEG data, he would most likely be able to identify their Myers-Briggs personality type. The research suggests that personality type likely has much to do with common patterns of brain activity.

 Although this may seem to be only tangentially related to music, I am interested in this research and its application especially to music-making for a number of reasons. First, about halfway through the presentation (at 39:15), Dr. Nardi begins to discuss what happens in the brain when someone is in a state of flow. In this state, which Dr. Nardi describes as a type of holistic brain activity, the entire brain synchronizes so that each section of the brain shows the same frequency and amplitude. This frequency is one in which the brain is awake and alert, yet relaxed (it shows as light blue on an EEG). Dr. Nardi found that this state seems to occur either when someone is engaging in a specific activity that is characteristic of their personality type (for example, an INFP actively listening) or when someone is performing a task related to their interest and expertise. For instance, a professional musician entered a state of flow when he was playing and singing one of his own compositions; interestingly, however, he did not enter this state when performing a song by someone else. 

I can't help but draw parallels here to my previous post on Dr. Charles Limb's research on brain activity during improvisation. Again, here is an instance of a musician entering a very specific brain state when performing music he himself has generated, but not music written by someone else. The act of performing original music - whether improvised or composed - seems demonstrably different than the act of performing memorized music by others. I am intrigued by the implications of this for classical musicians. Is a state of flow necessary for good performance? (Most of the participants did not seem to be consciously aware of when they were in this state). Can this state be achieved in a memorized performance? It would seem so, as some of Dr. Nardi's subjects who were theatre students were in a state of flow when performing a memorized and rehearsed scene. 

Perhaps even more interesting than the question of flow is that of personality type and brain activity. As a performer and a teacher, I would be fascinated to see a study similar to Dr. Nardi's with a focus on musicians. Specifially, I would love to know which sections of the brain were active in the different personality types while performing or otherwise engaging with music. It seems to me that differing patterns of brain activity may help to explain why some musicians seem to be "natural" performers while others are described as "wooden"; why some have a particular affinity for text delivery; why some are rhythmically precise but seem to struggle with melodic phrasing, or vice versa; and why musicians are drawn to certain specialties such as opera or early music. Might performers be helped by knowing their type and thus having a sense of their natural preferences as well as those areas that are difficult? Might teachers be able to better target their teaching to each individual student if they knew that student's type? Do different types enter a state of flow under different conditions, in response to different stimuli? I believe that these questions are worth investigating, as they may have the potential to assist teachers, students and performers in overcoming some of the more frustrating, intangible hurdles associated with music making. 

Music in Dreams

Source

Uga, Valerie, Maria C. Lemut, Chiara Zampi, Iole Zille, and Piero Salzarulo. "Music in
            Dreams."
 Consciousness and Cognition 15 (2006): 351-57. Science Direct. 21
            Oct. 2005. Web. 16 Oct. 2013.

Review

       The presence of music in dreams is something that is talked about to a great extent anecdotally, but is not documented too widely within the scientific community. This study seeks to determine the correlation between levels of musicianship and the frequency with which music occurs in dreams. Both professional and non-professional musicians kept dream journals to reveal how often music is a part of their dreaming process.
            The content of dreams are often associated with normal, everyday behaviours; however, there is not always a strong correlation between the frequency of these activities in our waking hours and their occurrence in dream states. In general, dreams are said to be “archaic” in the sense that they don’t make use of “relatively recent cultural acquisitions.” Furthermore, activities like reading, writing and typing which are fairly low yield, automatic skills, typically do not find their way into dreams. Music may be seen as more of a privileged domain since it can be both a conscious activity and an expression of competence. Even young children show general musical aptitude, though to achieve more sophisticated musical abilities, lifelong training and practise is necessary. The implications of this training and its relationship to the frequency of music in dream states are explored in this study. 
            Though this has been a topic that has not received a lot of exploration in scientific literature, previously studies have shown that the recall of specific musical themes is rare in the general public. In the context of musicians’ dreams, other studies explored the spontaneous occurrence of particular musical themes, as well as the effect of listening to music before bed on a variety of dream states. Anecdotal evidence from famous composers like Berlioz and Stravinsky suggest that original musical material may be composed in dream states.
            In this study, 35 professional musicians and 35 non-professional musicians took part. The professional musicians were all either instrumental or vocal performers of “Western tonal music” while the non-professional musicians were all undergraduate students. The study doesn’t indicate, or seem to allow for, professional musicians from a wider range of genres. Though participants had to fill out questionnaires indicating their level of musical study or ability, there is room for interpretation as to whether the “non-musicians” may have had some level of informal musical training or knowledge. As the study does acknowledge, even listening to music grows a certain kind of aptitude or knowledge.
            Each participant kept a dream journal for 30 days answering multiple-choice questions concerning dream recall, dream content and particularly the presence of musical/verbal activity. Based on the data, it was discovered that the two groups had similar results in regards to dream recall, dream content and the presence of verbal activity in dreams. However, the musician group had more than twice the dream recall than the non-musician group.
            The fact that the non-musician group still perceived some level of musical activity in their dreams demonstrates that the ability to deal with complex acoustic representations like music could be at work within dream processes. As I stated, this is in agreement with other studies which show that musical aptitude can be partly attributed to exposure to music of a particular idiom. In this way, the development of musical aptitude (not necessarily performance skills) is similar to language acquisition.
            In the musician group, there was also a correlation between the age when musical training started, and the level of music recall in dreams. The earlier the participants started studying music, the more frequent the musical recall was. On the other hand, there was no correlation found between the frequency of daily practise or musical activity and the amount of music present within dreams. Twenty-eight percent of the musical dreams logged by the participants claimed to be music that was never heard before. This has implications for the ability of people to compose music in their sleep, perhaps a result of the brain re-organizing and re-arranging musical fragments already present within our minds.

Reflection

            I became interested in this topic when, during the past week, I heard some hip-hop music quite vividly in a dream. In this particular dream, I was attempting to sleep, but the sheer volume of this music was preventing me from doing so. Upon waking up in real life, I could still hear this music in my head and had to get out of bed to clear my head. I woke up feeling like I had consciously heard some loud music blaring from another room. Yet, upon waking up, I was drawn back to the conscious realization that my apartment was normally silent.
            This got me thinking about the vividness with which we experience music in dream states. As this study reveals, I can relate to hearing melodies or fragments of music in dreams that I have never heard before. I have never remembered enough of this music upon waking up to write any of it down, but anecdotally, friends have shared with me stories of waking up in the middle of the night and frantically scribbling down bits of music that they heard while dreaming.
            The study also finds that 17% of the music heard during dream states occur in an unusual format. In other words, familiar music is manipulated and recognized as only somewhat resembling the original form. In a sense, different musical elements could be separated and re-combined with other musical fragments to create unusual musical material. This idea seems to connect to the experience of dreams in general since they often portray life events in an altered and sometimes twisted way. 
            There are strong implications if our mind is actually capable of creating some form of music, which is usually a conscious cognitive process, in a sleep state. It brings into question how deeply our musical activities are embedded into our psyche. This discussion also relates to Jourdain’s ideas about where inspiration comes from. He cites many examples of composers claiming divine inspiration for their work, composers who work in fits of madness or psychosis, and composers who feel like some muse informs their work. This study certainly reveals to me that there is a lot musically that can happen at the subconscious level while our brains re-organize, re-connect and re-arrange musical fragments to form new musical material.

http://www.brams.umontreal.ca/cours/files/PSY-6441/Musique%20et%20reves/Uga_2006_Music%20in%20dreams.pdf



Does music make you smarter?

Reference

Does music make you smarter? by Steven M. Demorest and Steven J. Morrison.
http://www.jstor.org/stable/pdfplus/3399646.pdf?acceptTC=true&acceptTC=true&jpdConfirm=true

Summary

“Does music make you smarter?” Most of this attention has centered on two sets of studies done by a group of researchers at the University of California at Irvine. The first series of studies documents a short-term increase in performance on a spatial reasoning task after listening to Mozart, often referred to as the "Mozart effect." The second series concluded that piano instruction caused preschoolers to improve on a single test of spatial reasoning ability. Steven M. Demorest and Steven J. Morrison address the specific results of the studies, discuss where they are most often misinterpreted or overstated, and identify alternative points that music teachers may wish to emphasize.

Smarter at what?

They mentioned, of course, music instruction makes students in music but most people misunderstand “music makes you smarter.” In all the recent press about the potential benefits of music and music instruction, there is an implicit assumption that "smarter" means "smarter at something else."

The “Mozart Effect”
"Mozart effect" refers specifically to improvement on a single spatial reasoning task exhibited by college students after ten minutes of listening to Mozart's Sonata for Two Pianos, K. 448, as demonstrated in a 1993 study, the conclusions of which were retested in a 1995 study. It involved seventy-nine college students taking a single spatial reasoning test derived from a subtest of the Stanford Binet Intelligence Scale, thought by the authors to best represent spatial-temporal reasoning. After taking the test together the first day, the students were divided into three groups for days two through five. Prior to retaking the test, twenty-six students listened to ten minutes of silence, twenty-seven students to ten minutes of Mozart, and twenty-six to a mix of minimalist music, dance music, and spoken text. The group that listened to Mozart improved significantly than other groups. But interestingly, on a separate short-term memory test, the presence of music made no difference at all. The authors concluded that the Mozart group's improvement was due to listening, while the silence group's improvement was due to a learning curve. “Several attempts by other researchers to replicate the Mozart effect under similar conditions have failed.” It is important to note that the results of these studies apply only to a single spatial subtest from the Stanford Binet intelligence scale; so the effect is much narrower than general intelligence as measured by IQ and it may be inappropriate to apply these findings to the musical education of children.

Keyboard Training
Several famous quotes illustrate the ways in which the results of some studies have been used to support the idea of a connection between music education and math and science. Most of studies had similar concepts; one group took lesson regularly and the other did not. The results could just as easily be stated, "Keyboard training has no impact on three out of four tests of spatial intelligence" or "Keyboard training helps children assemble puzzles rapidly," not quite the same as increasing their aptitude for math or science. As with the Mozart studies, the non-musical benefit was realized only for a very specific type of reasoning measured by a single standardized subtest.

National School Boards Association (NSBA), said, "I'm here to tell you that NSBA supports raising student achievement, and we know music can do that. Students who participate in music earn higher grades and score better on standardized tests. it has been reported that music students receive higher grades in math, English history, and science; higher test scores in reading and citizenship; and more general academic recognition than students who do not participate in school music activities. For SAT scores data, average SAT scores for music students are, indeed, above the average for all students and well above the average scores of students not participating in school fine arts study. However, they are not the highest. Math and verbal scores of students enrolled in acting and verbal scores of students studying drama appreciation were even higher. Additionally, scores of students enrolled in music appreciation were higher than those of students participating in music performance. “If we wish to argue that part of music's value lies in its correlation with higher test scores, we must also acknowledge that the study of acting and drama may be more valuable and that membership in a music appreciation class may be more valuable than ensemble participation.”

Reflection

We, musicians, all heard about “Music makes you smarter” concept and I was always wondering if this idea is right or wrong; through this article, it really helped me to understand this idea. First of all, I was surprised that “Music makes you smarter” is not quite right since I, somewhat, believed in this concept would be correct. Personally, I thought “Mozart Effect” study was ridiculous and inappropriate; especially the procedure of this study was absolutely preposterous. Of course, I would suggest and support people to listen Mozart’s music but how can we determine if someone gets smarter in five days?
Moreover, result that people who participate in fine arts get better SAT scores was intriguing. Along with this concept, I also have many friends who studied music at undergraduate and go to Medical school or Law school and I think there are some relations.
Overall, in my opinion, participating in music surely does not interfere with academic progress. Even from my own experience, when I was in high school, I had satisfying grades from all academic courses while I was taking all music courses. Plus, most of friends who were taking same music courses, they were also great at academic courses. Some people say, music and other arts as frills that distract students from more important subjects but I disagree with this idea. I support what authors said about participating in music, “Whether or not music increases children's brain power, it clearly doesn't hurt it. Thus, the path to academic excellence would seem to involve multiple avenues rather than the single road of reading, writing, and arithmetic.”

Building the Musical Muscle: Music in Individuals with Cochlear Implants

Reference: 
Charles Limb: Building the Musical Muscle
http://www.ted.com/talks/charles_limb_building_the_musical_muscle.html

Summary:

In this talk, Dr. Charles Limb talks about cochlear implants, and the problem with these individuals perceiving music. 

The location of the cochlea is where we not only hear, but draw connections between what we hear and our emotional response to those things. Most people with a cochlear implant basically think music sounds bad, and will not listen to it, taking that element of beauty out of their lives. The "perfect" cochlear implant would obviously allow not only for language, but music as well, restoring the full range of hearing. Limb plays a short midi file excerpt of music to show an example of the difference between what an individual with full hearing perceives versus someone with a cochlear implant. Although the example he plays shifts pitches only up to a semi-tone, individuals with cochlear implants actually can perceive the pitches up to two octaves away from what is actually being played. 

Individuals with these cochlear implants not only have major problems perceiving pitch, but also differentiating the timbre of different instruments. Limb shows a slide of brain activity that happens with an individual during language, rhythm, and melody, and there is essentially no activity in the auditory cortex during a melodic example- like it is unrecognizable. Similarly when trying to distinguish between the sound of a trumpet and a violin, it is virtually impossible for an individual with a cochlear implant to do.

Capacity for music remains even when individual has hearing loss or complete deafness. Limb uses the example of Beethoven in this case to exemplify that he still composed music after his deafness, and still needed and wanted music to be a part of his life even when he could no longer hear it, or really perceive his own creations. Limb ultimately suggests that music can still be trained in those individuals with cochlear implants. He shows an example of a cat with the implant in. They have trained the cat to respond to the sound of a trumpet as a sign to get food, and although the cat responds to no other music sounds, it does recognize the sound of the trumpet when playing a melody.

Limb's suggestion that music can be trained in individuals is supported by an example that he shows of one of his deaf students playing piano. The student plays sensitively, and expressively although he cannot fully perceive what he is doing. In showing this, Limb jokes that the student can play piano, but that he knows he has  hearing problem because he has heard the student do karaoke, and it was horrible. 

This talk really emphasizes the importance of music as it relates to beauty and the quality of life. And that although technology has come quite far in this area, it still has further to go in order to restore full hearing to individuals with these implants, instead of only speech. 

Response:

I found this talk quite fascinating in several ways. First of all, that the restoration of hearing has already come so far is great, but to be honest having a cochlear implant sounds like a nightmare to me. To not have the ability to hear or perceive music in an enjoyable way would be horrible, and to have no way to remedy that is scary as well.

I was particularly interested by the brain scans that he shows, and the lack of activity exemplified during the sound of melody. Obviously the frequencies of music are much different from that of speech alone, and this is what creates the difficulty in developing a tool that will help to perceive all of these other frequencies in a pleasant way for the individual. Limb states that "there is very little cortical activity (during melody perception) compared to normal hearing control". In this scan, they said that they did each separate: speech, rhythm, melody. Because there was so little activity in the brain during melody, and there was similar activity during both speech and rhythm, it makes me wonder if the individual can perceive rhythm in the melody, or because of their perception of the melody if they cannot. I only wonder this because the scans basically show almost no activity in the brain during music.

Although I don't personally know anyone with a cochlear implant, it does make me interested in understanding what exactly they hear. I liked Limb's idea of "training" music into individuals with these implants, although he does not really give many ideas on how to do this, other than showing a cat who was trained to hear the trumpet. It also made me wonder about the ability to train music into these individuals, but then the difference between doing this with someone who developed hearing loss throughout their life, and someone who was born deaf and then got the implant. Would this change ones perception of the music, or not?

In summary, I think that this is an important area of research, and interesting to see the growth and developments in this area, especially as restoring music as a benefit of the full life experience in an individual with cochlear implants.

Friday, October 18, 2013


How Many Music Centers Are in the Brain?

Reference
Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences

Summary
This article discussed the modularity of music functions and complexities of this topic as a result of individual neurological variables in music processing.

Traditionally it was believed there was a simple left-right hemisphere division of music and language function:  music processed on the right, language on the left. 
However, Bever and Chiarello’s [1] work in 1974 revealed the hemispheric lateralization of music processing as a result of music training.  This finding has since been supported through various studies.

The author investigated brain activation patterns of non-musicians, amateurs, and professional musicians while processing harmonic and melodic discrimination tasks.  Results of this study indicated that while non-musicians and amateurs processed these tasks bilaterally in the frontal lobes and the right temporal lobe, the musicians processed them primarily in the left frontotemporal lobe.  It is believed that musicians activate the left hemisphere due to “inner speech” when listening to and analyzing music.  For example, they may automatically name intervals or harmonic elements when listening.  The author concluded that music processing areas are more determined by “the way of listening or processing” rather than “fixed music centers”.

Various studies have brought forth evidence of music modularity, often based on isolated music functions affected by brain lesion.  Evidence suggests time components of music are primarily processed in the left temporal lobe and pitch processed more in the right.

The author noted that discussion of modularity of music processing increases in complexity when it is acknowledged that music processing can take place on various hierarchical levels.  For example, time components may be identified as meter or rhythm.  Studies following brain lesion have demonstrated isolated neural networks to process meter or rhythm.

The challenge remains for science to delineate the brain anatomy with these potential music -processing areas.  In considering this, the authored noted yet another difficulty.  In a recent study [2] of individuals who had experienced small unilateral ischemic lesions of the temporal, parietal, or frontal lobe, had a range of impairments in auditory perception.  Also, a group of individuals who had a left hemispheric stroke demonstrated a range of disassociated impairments including rhythm, meter, interval, or contour regardless of whether the lesion was anterior or posterior  to the central sulcus.   The author noted that this indicates “widespread and individually developed neural networks” involved in music processing.  As a result, the author created a study to explore these individual factors.

In order to explore this, he created a study to determine if the way someone learned music would influence neural processing when they listened to music.   If the learning style influenced the neural process of listening, this could provide further insight into the individualized processing networks.

Three groups of 13-15 years olds were created for the study.  One group learned music with traditional instruction (declarative group).  A second group was engaged in musical experiences, such as singing or playing, as they were taught (procedural group).  The third group was the control group and did not receive any musical instruction.

Instruction lasted for 5 weeks.  Following this period, EEG measurements were taken while the students listened to music.  The results revealed that the declarative group had increased activation of the left frontotemporal lobes.  The procedural group had increased activation in the right frontal and bilateral parieto-occipital lobes.  These results confirm that music training influences brain activation patterns.

The author noted "brain substrates of music processing reflect the auditory learning “biography”, the personal experiences accumulated over time".  These experiences may include listening to music, learning to play an instrument, or being a professional musician.  The various musical representations while processing music also appear to be partly interchangeable and adaptable. That is not to say that there is no hemispheric specialization, or that there are not specific areas responsive to specific musical elements.  The point is that there is individualization of processing, due in part to the “biography” of the listener.

It was also noted that increased complexity of processing requirements results in increased complexity of neural network responses.  This may explain the more extensive neural network response of musicians than of non-musicians when listening to music as they are listening for, and recognizing, more aspects of the music.

The author concluded with recognition of the scope of the challenge of learning and understanding the modularity of music including the affects of the influence of personal biographies on the individualization of some aspects of music processing, and the ongoing plastic and adaptive responses of the brain.

Reflections

The individualization of certain aspects of neural processing of music seems, in some ways, to be a double- edged sword.  It makes the concept and application of modularity of music processing more complex, but at the same time it confirms  individualized, plastic responses to a musical stimulus.  This individualized, plastic response is encouraging news for professionals using music-based interventions to address cognitive impairments following acquired brain injury.  We can attribute specific function to specific brain area, and we know that the brain is plastic and able to adapt at some level following trauma.  This is foundational in rehabilitation science.   This article’s study on the plastic changes and differences in neural response of students as a result of (simply) a teaching style highlighted again the incredible potential of the brain to change.  It reminds one of the potential for change following consistent, experience-based stimulation in rehabilitative interventions.  The extensiveness of neural networks for music processing also demonstrates music’s efficacy as a multi-site neural stimulus, especially following trauma to the brain.

In addition to the concepts discussed in the article, I appreciated the author’s description of music, stating that it is not “a mere acoustic structure in time, or a stimulus created in a laboratory to fit a well-controlled experimental design, but a phenomenon of subjective human experience”.   He continues that it is not “based on a uniform mental capacity but on a complex set of perceptive and cognitive operations…”    This to me, acknowledges not only the complexity of music itself, but also the potential range of human response to it.   These are important factors to remember when studying music and the brain, its stimulus, its impact, and its therapeutic potential.




References:

1.     Bever, T.G. & R.I. Chiarello. 1974. Cerebral dominance in musicians and non-musicians. Science. 185:537-540.
2.     Schuppert, M., T.F.Munte, B.M. Wieringa, et al. 2000. Receptive amusia: evidence for cross-hemispheric neural networks underlying music processing strategies.  Brain 123: 546-559.

Thursday, October 3, 2013

Intimate live music performances and quality of life for dementia patients

Reference
Van der Vleuten, M., Visser, A., and Meeuwesen, L. (2012) The contribution of intimate live music performances to the quality of life for persons with dementia. Patient Education and Counseling, 89:484-488.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22742983

Summary
This study investigates the effects of live, vocal music performances on the quality of life of patients with varying severities of dementia. Multiple studies investigating the effects of music on dementia have previously shown that it decreases apathy, depression, and anxiety, and improves self-esteem, general expression, independence, memory, social interaction, and participation in meaningful activities. This publication is one of the first to describe the benefits of live music in particular on total quality of life. Previous investigations on the benefits of live music have been limited to the effects on levels of engagement and well-being  In this publication, live music is suggested as a form of complementary care that could be used in nursing homes.

 There are four types of music that have shown to have different effects on patients with dementia: music therapy, singing caregivers, background music, and live music.

 Music therapy is the targeted, intentional use of music as a therapeutic strategy, administered by a therapist, and designed for a specific patient. This has shown to alleviate pain, decrease stress, fear, and depression, and improve expression of emotions, memory, health, and communication.

 The singing caregiver seems to improve mood and expression of positive emotions. This also helps improve caregiver-patient relations, and can promote vitality in patients with advanced stages of dementia.

 Background music improves expression of positive emotions and promotes playfulness.

 Live music appears to have a greater effect on patients with dementia than any other type of music. It has shown to increase levels of engagement and well-being to a greater degree than recorded music, regardless of the degree of cognitive impairment. The authors state that this is due to the participation and social interaction involved in live music.

 In this study, live music was performed by professional vocalists wearing fairy-tale like outfits. These performers also had been trained to maximize audience participation by encouraging dancing, maintaining eye contact, and interacting directly with the patients. These performances also included visual props and spoken poetry.

 To assess total quality of life, this study used the following four parameters: participation, mental well-being, physical well-being, and residential conditions. Results were measured via 43 different characteristics, including body language, reaction when approaching, etc., which were allotted into one of the following subcategories: human contact, care relationship, communication, positive emotions, or negative emotions. These parameters were evaluated, following the performance, by the caretakers or family members of 45 dementia patients as either 1) decreased 2) did not change, or 3)increased.

The study found that live music had a positive impact on mental well-being, and participation, but did not affect physical well-being or residential conditions. The authors suggest incorporating live musical performances as part of complementary care for dementia patients. These findings also suggest that live music performances decrease patient anxiety, aggression, and depression, which in turn decreases the work load of caregivers.

Response

I think the conclusions drawn from this experiment are valid, and merit closer inspection. There is clearly a correlation between increased cognitive presence, expression of positive emotions, and live performances.

The initial concern I had regarding experimental design was that the responses were being evaluated by either family members or caretakers. This introduces an additional variable that was not addressed in the paper. I think it is extremely difficult for a family member to maintain complete objectivity when observing whether or not the performance is making their loved one happier, because that individual, on a deeply personal level, wants the patient to improve. It is likely impossible for the family member to remove an emotional bias. In order to work around this, the evaluations could be done by either care takers exclusively, or by a group of graduate students or volunteers both before and after the performance, in consultation with the care givers or family members. This way, one could insure that the observations were noticeable by a more objective party.

The second critique was that the authors state explicitly that in previous studies, live music increased levels of engagement and well-being due to participation and social interaction. In the review that was cited for this statement, the authors are very careful to explain that this is most likely due to participation and social interaction. This seems like a subtle difference, but what if the increase in well-being and engagement is due to the visual component that does not accompany recorded music? Could one play a music video and see similar responses in these parameters? Are these benefits due to a stimulation of both the auditory and visual systems, as opposed to the former in isolation? Could similar results be obtained by employing the use of Ipads instead? In all likelihood it is the social aspect of live music that seems to increase the overall quality of life to a greater extent than recorded music, but if these answers haven't been directly addressed, it can lead to false assumptions to make statements of this kind with absolute certainty.

 It is also important to create a control group, since in this case one cannot decisively say if the benefits were due to live music performance alone, or in conjunction with costumes, props, poetry, and direct interaction with the audience. The authors did comment that this would need to be improved upon in future studies.

 In summary, I feel this study makes a compelling case as to why live music should be incorporated into care strategies for dementia patients in old age homes. Despite some weaknesses in the preliminary study design, there is undeniably a correlation between improvement in quality of life and live music performance. It has certainly inspired me to organize more live musical performances for nursing homes in my community!